Tisanayang'ane umboni wosonyeza kuti Hitler sanali wodya zamasamba, ndikofunikira kudziwa komwe lingaliro lomwe adachokera, chifukwa mtsutsowu siwowoneka bwino. Anthu amene amati Hitler anali wodya zamasamba nthawi zambiri "anamva" za izo kwinakwake ndipo nthawi yomweyo anaganiza kuti zinali zoona. Panthawi imodzimodziyo, ngati mutawauza kuti Hitler sanali wodya zamasamba, iwo, atavomereza zamasamba ake popanda kukayikira, adzafuna umboni mwadzidzidzi.
Nanga n’cifukwa ciani amafunikila umboni wakuti Hitler sanali wodya zamasamba, koma safuna umboni wakuti iye analidi? Mwachiwonekere, anthu ambiri amafuna kukhulupirira kuti Hitler anali wodya zamasamba. Mwina amaopa zamasamba, poganiza kuti ndi zolakwika.
Ndiyeno lingaliro lakuti Hitler wotchukayo anali wodya zamasamba limawapatsa chifukwa chotsutsa lingaliro lonse lakusadya zamasamba m’njira imodzi yokha. “Hitler anali wosadya zamasamba, kotero kuti kusadya masamba pakokha kuli ndi vuto!” Inde, uwu ndi mkangano wopusa kwambiri. Koma mfundo yaikulu ndi yakuti anthu ambiri amafuna kukhulupirira, choncho safuna umboni uliwonse wosonyeza kuti Hitler anali wodya zamasamba, koma mwadzidzidzi amafuna kuti anthu amene amaganiza mosiyana.
Ngati mukuganiza kuti ndikukokomeza ntchito ya odana ndi zamasamba popanga nthano ya Vegetarian Hitler, werengani kalatayi yomwe munthu wina adatumiza kwa wolemba wopambana mphoto John Robbins, yemwe adalemba mabuku angapo okhudza ubwino wa zakudya zopanda nyama.
Inu amene mumati tonse tingakhale omasuka pazakudya zamasamba mukuwoneka kuti mwaiwala kuti Adolf Hitler anali wosadya zamasamba. Imafooketsa chikhulupiriro chanu, sichoncho? ()
Mulungu, tangoyang'anani izi: Zimafooketsa chikhulupiriro chanu, sichoncho? Ndikofunikira kwa anthu osadya zamasamba ngakhale Hitler anali wosadya zamasamba. Amakhulupirira kuti popeza kuti Hitler anali wokonda zamasamba, kusadya masamba mwa iko kokha n’kosavomerezeka. Mungakhale bwanji oseketsa chotere?
Anthu oganiza adzamvetsetsa kuti ngakhale Hitler anali wamasamba, zilibe kanthu. Izo “sizingafooketse chikhulupiriro chathu.” Nthawi zina anthu oipa amasankha bwino. Sizovuta kumvetsa. Ngati Hitler anasankha zamasamba, chinali chimodzi mwa zosankha zabwino kwambiri pamoyo wake. Ngati ankakonda chess, sizikananyoza chess. Ndipotu, mmodzi mwa ochita masewera a chess m'mbiri ya masewerawo, Bobby Fischer, anali wotsutsa-Semite, koma palibe amene anasiya kusewera chess chifukwa cha izo.
Nanga bwanji ngati Hitler anali mu chess? Kodi omwe samasewera chess ndiye anganyoze osewera a chess? Ayi, chifukwa anthu amene samasewera chess sasamala kuti ena amasewera kapena ayi. Iwo samamva kuopsezedwa ndi osewera chess. Koma pankhani yokonda zamasamba, zinthu zimasintha. Pano pali chisonkhezero chachilendo kwa iwo omwe amatsimikizira kuti Hitler sanadye nyama.
Ndipo ndithudi, ngakhale Hitler akanakhala wodya zamasamba, wakupha wina aliyense m'mbiri sanali. Tikadasunga zigoli, zikadakhala: Opha zamasamba: 1, Opha anthu osadya masamba: mazana.
Tsopano tikupita ku mkangano wodabwitsa: Hitler vs. Benjamin Franklin. Franklin anali wodya zamasamba pafupifupi chaka chimodzi, kuyambira zaka 16 mpaka 17 (), koma, ndithudi, anthu ochepa amadziwa za izo. Ngati wodya nyama auzidwa (molakwitsa) kuti Franklin anali wodya zamasamba, iwo mwamsanga adzafuna kudziŵa ngati anadyapo nyama, ndipo ngati avomereza kuti anadyapo, iwo adzanena mosabisa kuti: “Ha! Adzafuula mwachipambano, "Choncho Franklin sanali wodya zamasamba, sichoncho?!" Zimandimvetsa chisoni kwambiri kuona mikangano yambirimbiri ikuchitika pankhaniyi.
Izi ndizofunikira, chifukwa anthu omwewo ali ndi njira zofewa kwambiri za Hitler. Franklin amatha kudya nyama kamodzi pazaka zinayi zilizonse, ndipo zamasamba zake zikanatsutsidwa, koma ngati Hitler adadyapo mbatata - bam! – Iye ndi wamasamba. Izi ndizofunikanso chifukwa pali zambiri zomwe Hitler adadya nyama moyo wake wonse, koma amachotsedwa mosavuta ndi omwe amaona kuti Hitler ndi zamasamba.
Kwa Franklin, muyezo ndi wosiyana: Franklin anayenera kupewa nyama 100% ya nthawi yake, moyo wake wonse, kuyambira kubadwa mpaka imfa, mosasunthika, mwinamwake iye sangakhoze kuonedwa ngati wamasamba. Zili ngati kuganiza kuti Hitler, yemwe poyamba sankadya nyama, ndi wamasamba, ndipo Franklin, yemwe ankadya nsomba kamodzi pa zaka zisanu ndi chimodzi popanda nyama, sali. (Kuti timveke: monga tanenera kale, Franklin anali wosadya zamasamba kwa pafupifupi chaka chimodzi, koma ambiri sadziwa za izo. Ndikunena za kusiyana kwa miyezo yomwe anthu ali nayo kwa Hitler ndi wina aliyense.)
Ndiye kukhala wosadya zamasamba kumatanthauza chiyani? Anthu ambiri angavomereze kuti ichi ndi chosankha mwachidziwitso, mosasamala kanthu za chifukwa chake. Koma malinga ndi mfundo imeneyi, Franklin anali wosadya zamasamba kwa pafupifupi chaka chimodzi, ndipo nthawi yotsalayo sanali. Ponena za Hitler, palibe umboni wokhutiritsa wosonyeza kuti amatsatira zakudya zamasamba kwa nthawi yayitali kapena yochepa.
Ambiri amati adadya nyama m'ma 1930 (onani pansipa). Atatsala pang’ono kufa (mu 1941 ndi 1942) anadzinenera kukhala wosadya zamasamba, ndipo ochirikiza lingaliro lakuti “Hitler anali wosadya zamasamba!” gwiritsitsani kwa icho. Ndi iko komwe, Hitler sakanama kapena kukokomeza, sichoncho? Chabwino, ndikutanthauza, tikukamba za Hitler, ndani angaganize kutsutsa zowona za Hitler? Ngati simukhulupirira Hitler, mungakhulupirire ndani? Tikadayenera kusankha munthu m'modzi Padziko lapansi yemwe mawu ake tikadakhulupirira mopanda malire, akanakhala Hitler, sichoncho? Inde, timakhulupirira kuti mawu aliwonse olankhulidwa ndi Hitler akhoza kudaliridwa mopanda malire, popanda kukayikira ngakhale pang'ono!
Rynne Berry anawonjezera kuti: “Kufotokoza momveka bwino: Hitler ananena kuti ndi wodya zamasamba . . .
Ndipotu, anthu ambiri amagwiritsa ntchito mawu oti "zamasamba" pofotokoza zakudya zomwe sizili zamasamba, ndipo nkhani ya Hitler ndi chimodzimodzi. Nkhani ya pa May 30, 1937, yakuti, “Panyumba ndi Fuhrer,” inati: “Zimadziwika kuti Hitler ndi wosadya zamasamba ndipo samamwa kapena kusuta. Chakudya chake chamasana ndi chakudya chamadzulo chimakhala ndi gawo lalikulu la supu, mazira, masamba ndi madzi amchere, ngakhale nthawi zina amadzipukusa ndi chidutswa cha nyama ndikuchepetsa chakudya chake chopatsa thanzi ndi zakudya monga caviar ... "Ndiko kuti, Hitler akunena kuti wosadya zamasamba, ali ndi nkhani iyi m'malingaliro: ndi "wamasamba" amene amadya nyama. Zili ngati munthu akunena kuti, “Sindine wachifwamba! Ndimabera banki kamodzi pamwezi.”
Kwa amene amaumirira kuti mawu a Hitler onena za kusadya masamba m’zaka za m’ma 1940 ayenera kutengedwa m’lingaliro lenileni, apa pali mfundo yamtengo wapatali yochokera mu “Buku la Hitler” lonena za zochitika zake zatsiku ndi tsiku mu 1944: “Pakati pa usiku pakati pa usiku (Eva) anaitanitsa chotupitsa chopepuka ku supu ya kamba, masangweji ndi soseji." Ngati Hitler analidi zamasamba, anali wodya zamasamba.
M'munsimu muli nkhani zochepa za zakudya zenizeni za Hitler.
Kuchokera ku Evolution in Nutrition ndi John Robbins:
Robert Payne amadziwika kuti ndi wolemba mbiri ya Hitler. M’buku lake lakuti Hitler: The Life and Death of Adolf Hitler, Payne analemba kuti “kusadya nyama” kwa Hitler kunali “nthano” ndi “nthano” yolembedwa ndi Joseph Goebbels, Nduna Yofalitsa za Nazi.
Payne akulemba kuti: “Kudzinyinyirika kwa Hitler kunathandiza kwambiri m’chifaniziro chimene anachisonyeza ku Germany. Malinga ndi nthano imene anthu ambiri amakhulupirira, iye sankasuta, kumwa, kudya nyama, kapena kukhala ndi unansi uliwonse ndi akazi. Yoyamba yokha inali yolondola. Nthawi zambiri ankamwa mowa ndi vinyo wosungunuka, ankakonda kwambiri masoseji a ku Bavaria ndipo anali ndi mbuye wake, Eva Braun ... Ndi kudzimana kodzionetsera kumeneku, ananena kuti anadzipereka kotheratu kutumikira anthu ake. Ndipotu nthawi zonse ankangokhalira kukhudzika ndi zilakolako zake, ndipo mwa iye munalibe chilichonse chodziletsa.
Kuchokera ku Toronto Vegetarian Association:
Ngakhale kuti madotolo adapereka zakudya zamasamba kuti Hitler achiritse kufutukuka komanso kusadya bwino, olemba mbiri yake, monga Albert Speer, Robert Payne, John Toland, ndi ena, adavomereza kuti amakonda nyama, soseji ndi mbale zina za nyama. Ngakhale Spencer ananena kuti Hitler anali wokonda zamasamba kokha chiyambire 1931: “Nkoyenera kunena kuti kufikira 1931 anakonda kudya zakudya zamasamba, koma nthaŵi zina anapatukako.” Anadzipha mu bunker mu 1945 ali ndi zaka 56. Ndiko kuti, akanatha kukhala wodya zamasamba kwa zaka 14, koma tili ndi umboni wochokera kwa wophika wake, Dion Lucas, yemwe analemba m'buku lake Gourmet Cooking School kuti mbale yomwe ankakonda kwambiri, zomwe nthawi zambiri ankafuna - nkhunda zodzaza. “Sindikufuna kusokoneza chikondi chanu cha nkhunda, koma mungakonde kudziwa kuti Bambo Hitler, amene nthawi zambiri ankadyera ku hoteloyo, ankakonda kwambiri mbale imeneyi.”
Kuchokera ku The Animal Program 1996 edition yotchedwa Roberta Kalechofsky
Pofuna kunyozetsa omenyera ufulu wa zinyama, ochirikiza kafukufuku wa zinyama amanena m’nyuzipepala kuti Hitler anali wodya zamasamba ndipo chipani cha Nazi sankayesa nyama.
"Mavumbulutso" awa akuti amawulula kulumikizana koyipa pakati pa a Nazi ndi omenyera ufulu wa nyama ndikuchenjeza kuti omenyera ufulu wa nyama ndi ankhanza. Koma chowonadi chokhudza Hitler ndi chipani cha Nazi chili kutali kwambiri ndi nthano. Kuyankha kumodzi koyenera ku zonena zotere ndikuti zilibe kanthu ngati Hitler anali wosadya zamasamba; monga momwe Peter Singer adanena, "Chenicheni chakuti Hitler anali ndi mphuno sichikutanthauza kuti tidzadula mphuno zathu."
Mbiri ya Hitler ikuwonetsa kuti panali zotsutsana munkhani zazakudya zake. Nthawi zambiri amafotokozedwa ngati wamasamba, koma nthawi yomweyo ankakonda kwambiri soseji ndi caviar, ndipo nthawi zina ham. Mmodzi mwa olemba mbiri yake, Robert Payne (Moyo ndi Imfa ya Adolf Hitler), sanagwirizane ndi nthano ya kudziletsa kwa Hitler, polemba kuti chithunzichi chinakwezedwa dala ndi chipani cha Nazi kuti chiwonjezere chiyero ndi kukhudzika kwa fano la Hitler.
Wolemba mbiri ya moyo wake John Toland (“Adolf Hitler”) akufotokoza zakudya za ophunzira za Hitler kukhala “mkaka, soseji ndi mkate”.
Kuphatikiza apo, Hitler sanalimbikitse kusadya zamasamba monga lamulo la anthu pazifukwa zaumoyo kapena zamakhalidwe. Kuperewera kwa chithandizo cha zamasamba kumalankhula momveka bwino za mtsogoleri yemwe adalimbikitsa mwamphamvu ndondomeko ya thanzi, malamulo oletsa fodya ndi chilengedwe, komanso njira za amayi apakati ndi obereka.
Mphekesera zoti chipani cha Nazi chinakhazikitsa lamulo loletsa vivisection zilinso zotsutsana kwambiri. Panalibe lamulo lotero, ngakhale kuti chipani cha Nazi chinali kunena za kukhalapo kwake. Vivisection Prohibition Act idakhazikitsidwa mu 1933.
The Lancet, nyuzipepala yotchuka yachipatala yaku Britain, idawunikiranso lamuloli mu 1934 ndikuchenjeza otsutsa vivisection kuti kunali koyambirira kwambiri kukondwerera, popeza sikunali kosiyana kwenikweni ndi lamulo la Britain lomwe linaperekedwa mu 1876, lomwe limaletsa kafukufuku wa nyama koma silinaletse. izo. . Madokotala a chipani cha Nazi anapitirizabe kuyesa nyama zambiri.
Pali umboni wochuluka wokwanira woyesera zinyama. Mu The Dark Face of Science, John Vivien akufotokoza mwachidule:
"Kuyesera kwa akaidi, chifukwa cha kusiyana kwawo konse, kunali ndi chinthu chimodzi chofanana - zonsezi zinali kupitiriza kuyesa nyama. Zolemba za sayansi zotsimikizira izi zimatchulidwa m'mabuku onse, ndipo m'misasa ya Buchenwald ndi Auschwitz, kuyesa kwa nyama ndi anthu kunali mbali ya pulogalamu yomweyi ndipo inkachitika nthawi imodzi. Ndikofunika kuti anthu adziwe zowona kuti nthano zonena za Hitler ndi chipani cha Nazi zisagwiritsidwe ntchito motsutsana ndi odya zamasamba ndi omenyera ufulu wa nyama.
Omenyera ufulu wa zinyama sayenera kulola kuti zonena zolakwa zimenezi zionekere m’manyuzipepala popanda kutsutsidwa. Tiyenera kubweretsa choonadi kwa anthu. Roberta Kalechofsky ndi mlembi, wofalitsa, ndi pulezidenti wa Jewish for Animal Rights.
Michael Bluejay 2007-2009